Make room in the trophy case

Published June 16, 2009 4:00am ET



A year ago the Capitals returned home from the NHL Awards Ceremony in Toronto with a truckload of hardware. Alex Ovechkin was named MVP and picked up three other major awards. Coach Bruce Boudreau earned the Jack Adams Award as NHL coach of the year.

On Thursday in Las Vegas, Ovechkin again is a finalist for the Hart Trophy and the Pearson Award (NHL players’ MVP) while Mike Green is up for the Norris Trophy as best defenseman. So do the Caps need a bigger trophy case?

Hart Trophy

In 2008 there would have been a riot if Ovechkin hadn’t been named MVP. This season? His chances are 50-50. Pittsburgh center Evgeni Malkin had a brilliant regular season with 35 goals and 78 assists. That gives him three more points than Ovechkin (56 goals, 54 assists — 110), who did play in three fewer games. Malkin led the NHL in takeaways (94). Ovechkin was a bit more productive on the power play with 47 points. The dark horse is Detroit’s Pavel Datsyuk, an elite two-way center second to Malkin in takeaways (89) who still managed 97 points.

The pick »  Split the difference. Malkin wins the Hart while Ovechkin takes the Pearson Award as the players’ choice.

Norris Trophy

No, Green isn’t a classic big defenseman like Boston’s Zdeno Chara, who can clear out a crease and still bomb shots from the point. Green also isn’t like Nicklas Lidstrom, the 39-year-old Red Wings star who plays the angles so well and always keeps the puck out of trouble. But at what he does — score goals, take chances, use his superb skating ability to recover from mistakes — Green did better than anyone in the NHL last year. Despite playing in just 68 games, he finished with 31 goals — the most by a defenseman since 1992-93. He also had an NHL-record streak for a defenseman of eight games in a row with at least one goal. Green’s .46 goals-per-game average is tied for seventh-best in league history.

The pick »  Green. The Norris shouldn’t just be handed to the defenseman with the most points. But we may not see an offensive season like this for a while.